Benevolence by Cynthia Holz

Benevolence, Cynthia Holz

Vintage Canada, 307 pages

ISBN 9780307398901


Renata Moon is a clinical psychologist.  Day after day, she sits in her office, listens to her patients talk through significant issues, and helps them find their way to happier, more fulfilling lives.  And after her last patient leaves, Renata closes the door and grieves the children she cannot have.

Ben Wasserman is a psychiatrist.  He sits on an ethics committee at a large hospital in Toronto, interviewing potential candidates for organ transplants and then deciding which candidates are the most worthy recipients for the limited supply.  When he thinks of the successful candidates, he knows that his work makes a difference in the world, but then he hears the sad stories of the unsuccessful candidates and heads straight to a rundown bar to drown his sorrows.  It isn’t ideal, but it’s more comforting than coming home to stilted conversation with an exhausted Renata over nondescript takeout.

And then Renata begins to see Stella, a young woman with powerful phobias, and slowly becomes drawn in by her kindness, generosity, and acceptance of the world for what it is.  And Ben interviews Arthur, a middle-aged man who wants very much to donate a kidney to a neighbour he has known casually for twenty years. Impressed by Arthur’s altruism and a shared love of poetry, Ben agrees to meet occasionally for a drink.  When Stella invites Renata to take an active interest in her pregnancy, and when Arthur invites Ben to visit his home in a nearby town, Renata and Ben must decide whether blurring the boundaries is a step worth taking.

In Benevolence, Holz explores of the themes of growth, healing, and the importance of goodness.  Delivered in an understated and confiding narrative voice, this latest work by Holz should appeal to readers of Zoe Heller, Elizabeth Hay and Carol Shields.

This entry was posted in Older Reviews and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Benevolence by Cynthia Holz

  1. This sounds interesting, Naomi. Thank you for sharing.

  2. Alex says:

    Not a writer I’ve come across before, but certainly a subject I would find interesting. The question of stepping over boundaries between professionalism and friendship is one that is always there for those of us who work in HE as well so I’m sure I would find much to identify with.

  3. Naomi says:

    My husband went to an in-service about crossing boundaries when he was a new teacher. The session leader told him that boundary crossing is most likely to happen when a needy teacher connects with a needy student. I thought Benevolence did a good job of illustrating the predicament without vilification, and it helps that the boundary-crossing is absolutely nonsexual in nature.

  4. I’ve just committed myself to reading and reviewing two books – you make it seem so easy – I’m a nervous wreck!

    • Naomi says:

      You’ll do fine! You write a wonderful blog and you’re interested in books, so I’m sure it’ll go well. I’ve been reviewing for about a decade in one form or another, but the reviews still take me a long time to write. I’m glad I do it, though – it makes me solidify my own reactions to what I’ve read and tends to guide me towards better books.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s